A Pilot's Log Book 


Tue, 16 Jan 2001 17:12:43 EST
Subject: Cutlass Bay Club/Cat Island
To: sandy@cutlass-bay.com

Dear Sandy - My name is XXX and we have never met.  Yesterday I was searching the Internet for an "Island Rental" opportunity for a family reunion-vacation sometime in the future.  I came across substantially developed sites at Darby Island and Musha Cay in the Bahamas and read the information with great interest because I visited the "Out Islands" many, many times a long time ago and I often flew over Darby Island.  This caused me to pull out my most recent edition of Bahamas & Caribbean Pilot's Guide (I was surprised to discover that I had the 2000 edition) to look at the exact
location of Darby Island in the Exumas.  Following that, I took a look at Cat Island, always our favorite destination, and at Cutlass Bay, where our Bahamas' experiences began, a very long time ago.  This led me to your website and the very sorry story reported as current events.  I will be very interested in your book when finished.  Your story will cover the 10 years you spent on Cat.  Let me give you some perspectives and what I remember of an earlier time.
 
My wife and I discovered Cutlass Bay quite by accident while overflying Cat Island on our way to Stella Maris on March 3, 1967.  The airstrip was not on the chart and looked new (it was) so we landed to take a look.  The club had been there only a short time and was being managed by a Canadian couple named Mary Jane and Bill (Kingsley?).  The cook was Mrs. Nottage and Mr. Nottage was the handyman/etc.  The club was apparently owned by a group including Herb Shriner, a then nationally known comedian.  I remember the taxi driver, Arthur Bain and "Haus Rebecca" where he took us for a drink.  The airstrip had aviation fuel for sale, and there was quite a bit of dive equipment and at least two boats for fishing and water skiing.  Things were good!
 
We enjoyed our two week stay very much and returned for another week in November of 1967 (flying logbooks document your life like nothing else) and on this trip we met Mike Kennedy, a redheaded Irish rough and ready guy who had apparently built the place.  In March of 1968 my wife and I stopped in Georgetown, Great Exuma, on our way to Puerto Rico and while having coffee at the Two Turtles Inn, Bill Kingsley walked in.  Quite a shock!  He told us
they had taken over management of a new club just down the road on Little Exuma, so we visited for a few days.  Not long after that, Bill crashed in a  Skymaster that he was allegedly flying for the Bahamian Police.  This occurred up north at Mores Island in Abaco.  A friend of mine, Fritz Luddington, who owned the Two Turtles Inn, later told me that Bill was sporting many bullet holes in his chest when they brought his body back to Exuma.  Our interests in Cat Island were renewed by the various stories, so we flew over to Cutlass Bay for a look.  Well, the club was not really open, but the Nottages were there as was Mike Kennedy and two architects/contractors from Florida who were building first a small house and then a large house for Bob Graf, who owned Graf Jets, a Learjet dealer in Ft Lauderdale, who we later came to know very well.
 
Our next visit to Cutlass Bay was in November of 1968.  Things were relatively good but somewhat downhill from our earlier visits and we again returned in October of 1970.  On this visit we met Ron and Jill Bamber who had built a very nice home with a few rental rooms at Fernandez Bay.  We stayed with them several times for a few days and for two weeks in November of 1971.  Ron seemed always to be in a feud with a young guy named Tony Armbrister who lived next door.  Tony seemed somewhat sinister to me.  I got to know his brother well who was a lawyer in the US.  I was trying to buy property on Cat Island and he was very helpful - fortunately, as the future
unfolded, it was good that I was not successful with this project.
 
We returned to Cutlass Bay for our family Christmas vacation in 1972 and Mike Kennedy and his wife, Melinda, seemed to be managing the place at that time, but everything was shrouded in mystery.  I offered to buy some land and jointly finance an extension of the airstrip but the plan never got off the ground because Mike never followed through on anything.  By this time Hawk's Nest had been constructed but I do not remember when the airport was built. The first manager landed his Piper Cherokee on the road prior to the building of the airport.  While visiting Hawk's Nest we discovered a house then called"Point House" that was owned by a man named Bob Green who lived in New Jersey.  We rented that house for two weeks each Christmas for four years, 1975, '76, '77 and '78.  The caretaker's name was Henry Rolle and his wife Rosibell did the baking for us.  They lived in McQueens, just down the road.
 
One very stormy evening during our Christmas vacation of 1978 a very large freighter appeared on the horizon and to our astonishment entered the harbor at Hawk's Nest Creek.  The opening to the harbor was only about 5 feet wider than the ship!  That night 38 airplanes landed at Hawk's Nest notwithstanding the fact that the visibility was not more than a mile and the ceiling was very low also - no navaids, no GPS, no LORAN in aircraft, etc.  I went through the brush to the edge of the airstrip and an aircraft was being fueled from a drum using a portable electric pump with a garden hose.  There had been no guests at hawk's Nest, which seemed strange to us.  The next morning it was bright and clear and I walked down to the dock to see the ship.  It was gone and "Red", the dockmaster told me that a cargo of lumber and cement had been unloaded during the night.  There was no lumber and cement to be seen, however.  Later that morning 6 unfamiliar men walked by the Point House carrying automatic weapons.  That was enough for us - we quickly packed up our things and our children and took off terminating our vacation a few days early.  My logbook shows that date to be January 6, 1979.
Following that experience, we did not return to the Bahamas until Christmas of 1984.  Cutlass Bay was full, so we stayed at Bob Graf's small house, just east of the club.  Things seemed strange, although Bob had built a hanger and had a Cessna 421 and a small single engine Piper Cub like plane, which we had great fun flying around the area.  Bob basically warned me not to ask any questions and not to think about building a home on Cat Island.
 
The last chapter of this story is that I returned to Hawk's Nest in a
chartered power boat in October of 1986 and spent two nights in the harbor as well as a number of days scuba diving at Columbus Point, Port Howe, Devil's Point and just to the west of Hawk's Nest point.  I learned that "Red" had been shot and killed but I could not track Henry Rolle down or learn much of anything else.  I am curious to know what has become of all these people. Fritz moved on to Provo and has been dead for some time and Bob Graf dropped dead in an airport but I know nothing of any of the rest.
 
Now you know why I am eager to read your book.  I know a lot of Cat Island history - I even knew Father Jerome!
 
Once again, I was very unhappy to read your news.  I thought all of the drug problems would be long past by now and we have been thinking about a trip to the Bahamas to visit the old haunts.  Sounds like that is not a good idea!